Andy Dalton
QB #3 — Philadelphia Eagles
More Philadelphia Eagles Players
About Andy Dalton
Andy Dalton has been in the NFL since 2011, has started for four different franchises, and is now employed by the Philadelphia Eagles for the sole purpose of existing on the depth chart behind Jalen Hurts. His actual job is to hold a clipboard, wear a headset, and be ready. His cultural job is to serve as the emergency broadcast system for Eagles Twitter every time Hurts takes a hit that looks slightly worse than normal. The moment Hurts limps, grabs his knee, or stays down for half a second too long, the words "IT'S OVER" start trending alongside photos of Andy Dalton warming up on the sideline. This happens roughly four times per season and has never once resulted in Dalton actually entering the game.
The Red Rifle nickname comes from his time in Cincinnati, where he was a perfectly competent starting quarterback who won a lot of regular-season games and zero playoff games. He's been a bridge starter in Dallas, a stopgap in New Orleans, a placeholder in Carolina. At every stop, the story was the same: Dalton is fine. He's professional. He's steady. He will not win you a championship and he will not lose you a game badly enough to get fired. He is the median of NFL quarterbacking, the absolute center of the bell curve, and in Philadelphia his mere presence on the roster has become a punchline, a panic button, and a philosophical question about what it means to have a backup plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do Eagles fans meme Andy Dalton so much?
Because the backup quarterback in Philadelphia is always a cultural figure, regardless of who it is. Philly has a long tradition of fans wanting to see the backup: it happened with Jalen Hurts behind Carson Wentz, with Nick Foles behind everyone, and now with Dalton behind Hurts. The moment the starter struggles, the backup becomes a folk hero through pure hypothetical potential. Dalton specifically gets memed because of the absurd contrast between his steady, unremarkable career and the apocalyptic energy Eagles fans bring to the 'should we start the backup' conversation.
What is the 'IT'S OVER' Andy Dalton meme?
Any time Jalen Hurts takes a hard hit, a segment of Eagles Twitter immediately declares the season finished and begins posting photos of Andy Dalton with captions like 'THE RED RIFLE ERA BEGINS.' It's partly ironic, partly genuine panic, and entirely predictable. Hurts could get up immediately and throw a touchdown on the next play, and the 'IT'S OVER' tweets would still have 5,000 likes before anyone could delete them. The meme is less about Dalton and more about the city's relationship with quarterback anxiety.
Last updated: April 2026